| Bored by democracy
In El Salvador, many people associate
the noise of helicopters with the 12-year civil war
that ripped apart this tiny Central American country. Yet late on March
7, seven years after the
war ended, helicopters ferried voting results from remote provinces
into the capital. The aircraft
landed on the lawn of a commercial mall across the street from where
politicians awaited the
official tally. As the aircraft repeatedly buzzed low over poor neighborhoods
on their way into
the capital, people hardly noticed the sound anymore.
Nor did they notice the elections. Less
than 40 percent of this country's 3.1 million eligible
voters bothered to cast a ballot for their country's next president.
Such a high level of abstention,
several observers note, signals serious problems for the country's
nascent democracy.
“In the transition after the war, we've constructed new institutions
and new rules of the
game, a new judicial apparatus, and a new institutional structure,
but we've made few efforts to
increase those civic values that have to accompany the institutions,”
Carlos Ramos, an
investigator at the Facultad Latinoamericana de Ciencias Sociales,
told LP. “We've constructed a modern political regime but we haven't
constructed a democratic culture. People have not come to associate the
functioning of the democratic system with the resolution of their fundamental
daily problems.”
So they stayed home.
It wasn't supposed to be this way. After
1997 legislative and municipal elections in which
the rightist Alianza Republicana Nacionalista (ARENA) barely defeated
the leftist Frente
Farabundo Marti para la Liberacion Nacional (FMLN), the 1999 presidential
elections were
supposed to be a showdown between the two parties, a contest in which
the left had a real chance to take over the executive branch. But as the
campaign got underway last year, the FMLN did everything wrong.
When the FMLN held a convention in August
to name its presidential candidate,
“everyone in the country was watching, there was tremendous media coverage,
it seemed like
the final election of the next national president,” Ramos said. But
the convention couldn't agree on one candidate, and the party needed two
more conventions to finally choose a compromise
candidate in September. In the process, the three most popular potential
candidates--San Salvador Mayor Hector Silva, former human rights prosecutor
Victoria Marina de Aviles, and political analyst Hector Dada--had withdrawn
their candidacies or refused to run. It was a bitter, and costly, internecine
fight.
“By the third congress, no one cared
any longer what happened,” Ramos said. “A six-year
struggle to construct a new image was thrown away in a month and a
half. After 1997, when
they presented themselves as an alternative force with a distinct type
of political practice, in 1998 they publicly exhibited their intolerance,
irrationality, and dogmatism.”
The FMLN's compromise presidential candidate,
Facundo Guardado, was crippled by his
guerrilla past (what commentators here refer to as “the smell of gunpowder”),
as well as by lack of support from some “orthodox” sectors of the FMLN.
Shafick Handal, head of the FMLN's
communist tendency, was almost entirely absent from the campaign, and
most of Handal's
followers simply didn't vote. Handal had argued privately that it was
better for the party not to win the presidential race this time around,
since he believes a major crisis in the country's economy is looming three
or fours years from now. It would be better, according to Handal, for ARENA
to take the blame for that.
The campaign of Guardado and vice presidential
candidate Nidia Diaz was also debilitated
by a popular perception that they were trying hard to be something
they weren't. “The leftist
candidates dressed up and used a different language so as to not scare
off the economically
powerful. They put on suits to get their photo taken in book-lined
libraries, and they used
language different from how people talk on the streets,” feminist leader
Morena Herrera told LP.
“The rightwing candidates appeared in short-sleeve shirts, walking
with the people, talking about
the problems of ordinary people.”
The FMLN's approach, said Morena, a
former guerrilla leader, “didn't fool the rich and it
turned off the poor.”
ARENA's presidential candidate, Francisco
Flores, seemed to do everything right.
ARENA washed its dirty laundry in private,
and Flores presented a united front. The 39-year old philosophy professor,
chosen in a February 1998 party congress, portrayed himself as different
from the bloody rightists, like Roberto D'Aubuisson, who formed ARENA as
an fanatical anticommunist party during the height of the war. Although
ARENA's party hymn speaks of El Salvador as the tomb of “the reds,” Flores
commissioned rap artists to bring it up to date.
Although ARENA had won the last two presidential elections, Flores
sold himself as the
candidate of change.
Flores led pre-election polls for months,
and his victory was no surprise. His absolute
majority of 51.96 percent avoided a second round of voting. Guardado,
whose FMLN joined in an electoral coalition with the small Union Social
Cristiana, garnered 28.88 percent. Ruben Zamora, the FMLN's 1994 presidential
candidate, got 7.59 percent as the candidate of the five-party Centro Democratic
Unido coalition.
Sometime before he takes office on June
1, Flores will name his cabinet. It will be the first
post-electoral sign of whether he really brings new perspectives to
the presidency or whether
he's just “the pretty face of the inner circles” of ARENA hardliners.
He has promised a cabinet
composed of qualified people from all political backgrounds, but former
President Alfredo
Cristiani warned the day after the elections that Flores had better
stick to ARENA faithful.
Should Flores wander far from the party leash, Salvadorans may begin
to speak of his administration and the ARENA party as two distinct entities.
The FMLN faces months of political wrestling
as it looks for scapegoats for the electoral
loss. It will have to get its house in order quickly, however, if it
wants to recover in time for the
legislative and municipal elections next year.
- From San Salvador, Paul Jeffrey
Sidebar: Women target 2000 vote
During 1997 midterm elections, Salvadoran
voters gave the leftist FMLN control of half
the country's cities, including the mayor's office of the two largest
cities. The FMLN also won
27 seats in the Asamblea Legislativa–just one less than the ruling
ARENA.
Besides the left's competitive showing
two years ago, women candidates did better than
ever. The FMLN's legislative bench includes ten women, for example.
Of 1,320 city council
members elected nationwide from all parties, 235 are women. Twenty-two
of the country's 240
mayors are women. The numbers remain small compared to women's share
of the population,
but feminist activists insist it's a sign that things are changing.
On March 23, women mayors and city council
members from around the country will
gather to plot strategy for next year. Their goal is to double the
number of elected women
politicians. They believe the results of this year's voting, when many
women stayed home, give
them new space to demand that political parties give women a chance
as candidates.
“We've sent a message that we are not
unconditional supporters,” declared Morena
Herrera, a leader of Las Dignas, a leftist feminist group.
If political parties don't respond adequately,
Herrera said, women may go it alone next year
or form a coalition with the country's budding environmental movement.
Many feminists who might otherwise have
supported the FMLN had their party fervor
chilled in February when the Asamblea Legislativa passed a constitutional
amendment banning
abortion. Not one legislator voted against the motion. Fourteen FMLN
deputies supported the
constitutional amendment, and 12 FMLN deputies abstained.
The Asamblea vote was part of a recent
crackdown on abortions in this country. In April
of last year the Asamblea strengthened criminal penalties, allowing
for up to eight years in prison
for women who obtain abortions and for doctors who perform them. There
are no exceptions
for rape or incest. In the last half of 1998, the government brought
abortion charges against 20
women, compared to only five prosecutions during the previous six months.
While most of the participants in the
March 23 meeting will likely be women elected as
FMLN candidates, women in ARENA are also chafing at the machista attitudes
of party
leaders.
One prominent woman politician, Ana
Maria de Gamero, the vice-ministra de salud
publica, said recently she was tired of always being asked in ARENA
meetings to serve on the
party's committees dealing with women's affairs. “If I serve on the
women's committees, then my
job becomes arranging rooms before meetings and preparing the food,”
complained de Gamero.
- PJ
|