The Shepherd's Musings

Recent discussions about the status of church property and real estate have brought to my attention some confusion and concern about how these matters are handled in The United Methodist Church. Does the congregation own its church property, or is church property owned by the annual conference? Why does there seem to be so much red tape surrounding the care and disposition of church real estate? I hope the following will help clarify some of these matters.

Local church real estate is always owned in trust for the Annual Conference of The United Methodist Church. That means that the local congregation has primary control and responsibility for the care of its property, but it does so for the benefit of the mission of the whole United Methodist Church in the Annual Conference in which a local church is situated. Therefore, when a local church is proposing to sell or make major changes to its real estate, it is required to seek the approval of the annual conference through a district board of church building and location. It is the responsibility of the board to make sure that a local church’s plans for property are in the best interest of the mission of the denomination.

What happens to church property if a congregation must discontinue its existence? Typically, the property is transferred from the holding of local church trustees to holding by the annual conference board of trustees, who make any further decisions regarding the property’s disposition.

All of this is rather different from our individual experiences of owning real estate in our Western capitalist society. However, we might compare it to how property and real estate ownership was regarded in ancient Israel. Property was granted to the Hebrew tribes upon their entry into Canaan, and families in a particular tribe were in turn granted land to be held in perpetuity by the family. It was intended that no generation could ever sell family property permanently. One generation of a family held land in trust for succeeding generations of the family.

We hold in trust the property we have for the whole “tribe” called the Central Pennsylvania Conference of The United Methodist Church. Moreover, we hold it in trust for succeeding generations of United Methodist Christians, who will pursue the mission of the church in this place. Having designated people who are a part of this extended family, called the Annual Conference, give approval to local church proposals regarding property and real estate helps us to be sure we are doing the best not only for the church as it is today, but for the church as it will be in future generations.

Grace and Peace,

Pastor Brand Eaton

Central Pennsylvania Conference

The space for this web site has been provided courtesy of the General Board of Global Ministries, The United Methodist Church. The content of these home pages is the responsibility of Baughman Memorial United Methodist Church. Please send feedback to Baughman Church.